Skip to main content

Hypocrisy = "Shut Up!"

When a person calls another a hypocrite, even if it is true, he is saying "Shut Up!". It is an attempt to cause such shame that the hypocritical person will cease to oppose your ideas.

It removes from the discussion the rational analysis of the topic at hand. It is a bloodless assassination - it removes your enemy from the discussion, thus weakening the opposition.

To me, ideas stand on their own. Regardless of the hypocrisy, the goodness, or the badness of the person, the idea itself should be analyzed, not the person stating it.

The anti-jew statements made by a drunken Mel Gibson some months ago is an example. If I recall correctly, his statement was that "jews started all the wars in the world." Instead of refuting his unfounded statement, people were simply incensed by his "anti-semitism." Many vowed to never see another Mel Gibson movie.

Now, that is just ridiculous. Mel, and anyone else, is perfectly within his rights to dislike anyone he pleases. Perhaps he should be chastised for making such a derogatory statement about the jews, but the real point is that he is wrong. Nobody stepped up to point out that most of the wars in the world were NOT started by jews. All it would have taken is a credible historian to hold a little news conference and present the facts. That alone should be sufficient.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

St. Augustine on Curiosity ***

There is another form of temptation, even more fraught with danger. This is the disease of curiosity... It is this which drives us to try and discover the secrets of nature, those secrets which are beyond our understanding, which can avail us nothing and which man should not wish to learn.

- St. Augustine

***10/5/2013 - Note: this is probably a misquote, for the purpose of defaming St. Augustine.  I published it without any research as to its veracity, and I regret it.  He is a revered figure in Christianity and western culture, and whether we subscribe to his philosophy and views or not, everyone deserves at least to be described accurately. - James Carr.

Lieberman Agrees: Democrat Politicians are Paranoid Assholes

"But there is something profoundly wrong—something that should trouble all of us—when we have elected Democratic officials who seem more worried about how the Bush administration might respond to Iran’s murder of our troops, than about the fact that Iran is murdering our troops. "
- Senator Joe Lieberman, Nov 9, 2007



FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
November 9, 2007
Contact: Marshall Wittmann


Lieberman Delivers Major Address on "The Politics of National Security"




WASHINGTON, D.C. – On Thursday, November 8, 2007, Senator Joe Lieberman (ID-CT) addressed a Center for Politics and Foreign Relations/Financial Times breakfast at The Johns Hopkins University Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies. The subject of Senator Lieberman’s talk was “The Politics of National Security,” in which he spoke about the future of the Democratic Party and its response to the threat of Iran.



In the address, Senator Lieberman stated, “Since retaking Congress in November 2006, the top foreig…